Office of Solicitor General
The Office of the Solicitor General (“OSG”) is one of three divisions that comprise the Department of Justice (“DOJ”), which also includes the Tribal Police Department and Band Member Legal Aid. 24 MLBSA § 1053. The DOJ functions “within the Executive Branch of Government,” and principally operates from offices located at the Government Center. 24 MLBSA § 1051. The Solicitor General serves as the administrative supervisor of the DOJ, and the managing supervisor of the OSG, consisting of six Deputies Solicitor General and two administrative staff members. 24 MLBSA § 1054(g, i).
The current Solicitor General is Caleb Dogeagle.
About the Office of Solicitor General
The Solicitor General serves as lead Interior Legal Counsel of the Mille Lacs Band, and not solely as legal representative of the Executive Branch of government. 4 MLBSA § 16(a); 24 MLBSA § 1054(b). The Solicitor General is not considered an executive officer. 4 MLBSA § 4. Consequently, the Solicitor General does not sit on the Administration Policy Board. 4 MLBSA § 9(a). The Solicitor General nonetheless must adhere to the tribal Ethics Code due to his or her status as an appointed official. 6 MLBSA § 1153(a).
The OSG does not provide direct legal services to Band members, but rather represents the Band government and its employees, provided such individuals are acting in an official capacity. 4 MLBSA § 18(f); 24 MLBSA § 1054(b). The primary responsibility of the OSG is the objective interpretation, application, and enforcement of Band law. 4 MLBSA § 19(a-b); 24 MLBSA § 1054(f). The OSG maintains absolute independence in the performance of this obligation. 4 MLBSA § 18(b).
The authority of the Solicitor General finds its expression in several statutory titles, but principally in Titles 4 and 24, respectively entitled “Executive Branch” and “Judicial Proceedings.” The Solicitor General is responsible for representing the executive and legislative branches in the MLB Court of Central Jurisdiction. 2 MLBSA § 1108(b); 4 MLBSA § 16(a). This duty also extends within other courts of competent jurisdiction. 4 MLBSA § 18(a, c).
At times, tribal statute specifically denotes either the client or representational subject area of the OSG. 17 MLBSA § 13 (identifying specific duty to represent the Loan Committee before the Court of Central Jurisdiction); 18 MLBSA § 7 (identifying specific duty to represent the Corporate Commission before the Court of Central Jurisdiction); 18 MLBSA § 422 (identifying specific duty to represent the Administration Policy Board in matters regarding Indian Employment Rights); 22 MLBSA § 1(k) (identifying specific duty to represent the Commissioner of Finance in matters regarding taxation); 8 MLBSA §§ 16, 3122 (emphasizing prosecutorial role in the context of juvenile proceedings); 9 MLBSA § 28(a) (clarifying advocacy role in relation to the School Board); 11 MLBSA §§ 8, 18 (addressing ability to seek injunctive relief to abate environmental degradation); 10 MLBSA § 119 (conferring statutory standing to appeal a Federation Cultural Resources Board determination). The OSG additionally provides general legal advice and counsel. 4 MLBSA § 18(f); see also 4 MLBSA § 18(e) (assisting in the drafting and amending of governmental laws, orders and policies); 4 MLBSA § 18(b) (upholding tribal laws, orders, judgments, policies, and contracts). Certain particular functions are also set forth in tribal statute. 4 MLBSA § 18(e) (certifying and codifying Band ordinances); 6 MLBSA § 1 (regarding duty to periodically amend the personnel policies and procedures); 24 MLBSA § 3361 (regarding duty to develop boilerplate forms relating to per capita withholding); 6 MLBSA § 2005(a) (determining whether a former or current Band official may be entitled to indemnification); 7 MLBSA § 26(b)(2) (reviewing procurement contracts that exceed $5,000.00 in cost); 22 MLBSA § 211(b, f) (exercising oversight of tobacco sales licensure); 3 MLBSA § 27(b) (confirming appropriate form and execution of legislative orders).
In conjunction with the foregoing, the Solicitor General may formally issue presumptively binding legal opinions. 4 MLBSA § 18(d). A Solicitor General Opinion gains the force of law if the Band Assembly declines to annul the opinion, in whole or in part, within five (5) days after its receipt, provided that the tribal Judiciary does not subsequently issue a contrary judgment. 3 MLBSA § 17; 4 MLBSA § 18(d). The OSG otherwise routinely renders informal legal opinions upon the request of elected and appointed officials.
Attorneys
Angel E.A. Daher
Managing Attorney
Date of Employment: November 16, 2015
Education:
Metropolitan State University, St. Paul, MN
1998, B.A. Philosophy
Hamline University School of Law, St. Paul, MN
2002, Juris Doctor
Experience:
Bruner Law Group, PLLC, Minnetonka, MN (Senior Attorney, 2015)
Aronson & Associates, P.A., Minneapolis, MN (Of Counsel, 2013-2014)
ICWA Law Center, Minneapolis, MN (Staff Attorney, 2004-2012)
Solo Practitioner, Minneapolis, MN (2002-2006)
OSG Practice Areas: Child Protection, Civil Litigation, Criminal Prosecution, Guardianship
Admissions: Mille Lacs Band of Ojibwe, State of Minnesota
Tribal Enrollment: Lac Courte Oreilles Band of Lake Superior Chippewa
Michael L. Hogan Jr.
Title: Deputy Solicitor General
Date of Employment: 2013-2017, 2018-present
Education:
Antioch College, Yellow Springs, OH
2004, B.A. Political Science
William Mitchell College of Law, St. Paul, MN
2009, Juris Doctor
Experience:
Minnesota Nurses Association, Labor Relations Specialist (2017-2018)
Minneapolis American Indian Center (2011-2013)
OSG Practice Areas: Child Protection, Civil Litigation, counsel to the Gaming Regulatory Authority
Admissions: Mille Lacs Band of Ojibwe; State of Minnesota; U.S. District Court, District of Minnesota
Emily Duven
Deputy Solicitor General
Date of Employment: September 17, 2018
Education:
University of Iowa, Iowa City, Iowa,
2003, B.S. Business Marketing
Hamline University School of Law, St. Paul, MN
2006, Juris Doctor
Experience:
Team Lead, KLD Discovery: e-discovery and team management of large e-discovery document review and litigation discovery.
Advisor, Sakallah Group: employment and human resources, business formation and development, property acquisitions, contract disputes and litigation
Contract Attorney, Minnesota Department of Transportation: Data Practices, prevailing wage and contractor disputes
Contract Attorney, Law Office of Michael D. Schwartz: business, employment and other civil litigation
OSG Practice Areas:
Child Protection, Child Support, Guardianship, Truancy
Admissions:
Minnesota Supreme Court, U.S. District Court - Minnesota, Mille Lacs Band
Charles W. Naughton
Deputy Solicitor
Date of Employment: September 8, 2020
Education:
Mankato State University, Mankato, MN 1995, B.S. Finance, Marketing and Pre Law
William Mitchell College of Law, St. Paul, MN 2005 Juris Doctor
Experience:
Associate Attorney, Hess & Jendro Law Office P.A., Elk River, MN
Berry Law Offices, Princeton, MN
Partner Scintilla Media, LLC, Minneapolis, MN
OSG Practice Areas:
Child Protection, Child Support, Adult Guardianship and Criminal Prosecution
Admissions:
Minnesota District Court
Federal District Court, District of Minnesota
Mille Lacs Band of Ojibwe Tribal Court
Benjamin L. Lundquist
Deputy Solicitor General
Date of Employment: September 2020
Education:
Gustavus Adolphus College, St. Peter, MN, 2012, B.S. Political Science, English
University of Oklahoma College of Law, Norman, OK, 2015, JD
Experience:
Associate Attorney, Midwest Disability, Minneapolis, MN
Associate Attorney, Baumert, Cummings & Hiatt, Ponca City, OK
OSG Practice Areas:
Child Protection, Truancy, Civil Litigation
Bar Admissions:
Mille Lacs Band of Ojibwe Tribal Court
Minnesota District Court
Oklahoma District Court
Former Solicitors General
“The Solicitor General shall serve a four-year term of office commencing May 1, 1987, and on this date every four years hence.” 4 MLBSA § 17(b).
Tadd M. Johnson, Esq.
Appointed/Served Term: 1988-1989, 2000-2002, 2006-2007, 2018
Education: University of Minnesota Law School, J.D. (1985)
Tribal Enrollment: Bois Forte Band of Ojibwe (Minnesota).
Todd R. Matha, Esq.
Appointed/Served Term: May 2, 2011-April 25, 2018
Education: University of Minnesota Law School, Minneapolis, MN
1996, Juris Doctor
Tribal Enrollment: Ho-Chunk Nation
Rjay J. Brunkow, Esq.
Appointed/Served Term: Nov. 27, 2006 – May 2, 2010
Education: University of Minnesota Law School, J.D. (2004)
Tribal Enrollment: Turtle Mountain Band of Chippewa Indians (North Dakota).
John S. Swimmer, Esq.
Appointed/Served Term: 2003-Mar. 27, 2006
Education: University of Wisconsin Law School, J.D. (1998)
Tribal Enrollment: Cherokee Nation (Oklahoma).
Mary Al Balber, Esq.
Appointed/Served Term: 2002-2003
Education: Hamline University School of Law, J.D. (1990)
Tribal Enrollment: Red Cliff Band of Lake Superior Chippewa Indians (Wisconsin).
Adam H. Altman, Esq.
Appointed/Served Term: 1999-2000
Education: University of Minnesota Law School, J.D. (1998).
James M. Genia, Esq.
Appointed/Served Term: 1993-1999
Education: William Mitchell College of Law, J.D. (1990)
Tribal Enrollment: Little Traverse Bay Bands of Odawa Indians (Michigan).
James F. Pence, Esq.
Appointed/Served Term: 1991-1993
Education: University of Minnesota Law School, J.D. (1971)
Tribal Enrollment: White Earth Band of Ojibwe (Minnesota).
Anita P. Fineday, Esq.
Appointed/Served Term: 1990-1991
Education: University of Colorado Law School, J.D. (1988)
Tribal Enrollment: White Earth Band of Ojibwe (Minnesota).
Joshua J. Kanassatega
Appointed/Served Term: May 26, 1983-1987
Education: University of Washington School of Law, J.D. (1990).
Former Senior Deputy Solicitors General
Stacey A. Thunder
Date of Employment: August 1, 2014
Education:
Hamline University, St. Paul, MN
1994, B.A. Psychology
William Mitchell College of Law, St. Paul, MN
1998, Juris Doctor
Experience:
Red Lake Band of Chippewa Indians, Red Lake, MN (Legal Counsel, 2005-2014)
Mille Lacs Band of Ojibwe Corporate Commission (Staff Attorney, 2001-2005)
Red Lake Band of Chippewa Indians (Attorney, 1998-2001)
Indian Child Welfare Law Center, Minneapolis, MN (Law Clerk, 1998)
OSG Practice Areas: Legislative
Admissions: State of Minnesota
Tribal Enrollment: Red Lake Band of Chippewa Indians
Michael L. Hogan, Jr.
Date of Employment: May 6, 2013
Education:
Antioch College, Yellow Springs, OH
2004, B.A. Political Science
William Mitchell College of Law, St. Paul, MN
2009, Juris Doctor
Experience:
Minneapolis American Indian Center (ICWA Court Monitor, 2011-2013)
Transport Designs, Inc., Burnsville, MN (Attorney, 2010)
Englemeier & Umanah, Minneapolis, MN (Clerk, 2009)
OSG Practice Areas: Child Protection, Civil Litigation, Criminal Prosecution, Guardianship
Admissions: Mille Lacs Band of Ojibwe; State of Minnesota; U.S. District Court, District of Minnesota
Barbara E. Cole
Dates of Employment: February 21, 2007 – October 8, 2015
Education:
University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI
2002, B.S. Political Science & Women’s Studies
University of Minnesota Law School, Minneapolis, MN
2005, Juris Doctor
Zachary H. Atherton-Ely
Date of Employment: February 13, 2012 – October 2, 2015
Education:
State University of New York, Geneseo, NY
2006, B.A. International Relations & Political Science
University of Minnesota Law School, Minneapolis, MN
2009, Juris Doctor
Richard D. Osburn
Dates of Employment: July 2, 2007 – November 19, 2008
Education:
University of Oklahoma, Norman, OK
1990, B.A. Spanish
University of Oklahoma College of Law
2000, Juris Doctor
Tribal Enrollment: Cherokee Nation
Treaty Protection
The Mille Lacs Band continues to adhere to its standing treaty obligations with the United States government. 2 MLBSA § 1001. The Solicitor General is entrusted with the responsibility of interpreting Band law as it relates to treaty rights, 2 MLBSA § 1108(a), and may initiate legal measures, including enlisting the obligatory assistance of the federal government, to protect these guaranteed usufructuary rights. 2 MLBSA § 1007. In particular, Band members, collectively and individually, maintain the “privilege of hunting, fishing, and gathering the wild rice, upon the lands, the rivers and the lakes included in the territory ceded” pursuant to the Treaty of 1837. Treaty with the Chippewa, July 29, 1837, art. 5, 7 Stat. 536, 537. Yet, “all treaties to which the Mille Lacs Band is a party shall have a status equal to the supreme law of all land under the jurisdiction of the Band.” 2 MLBSA § 1002.
- Treaty with the Sioux & Chippewa (Treaty of Prairie du Chien, Aug. 19, 1825, 7 Stat. 272)
- Treaty with the Chippewa (Treaty of Fond du Lac, Aug. 5, 1826, 7 Stat. 290)
- Treaty with the Chippewa (Treaty of St. Peters, July 29, 1837, 7 Stat. 536)
- Treaty with the Chippewa (Treaty of La Pointe, Oct. 4, 1842, 7 Stat. 591)
- Treaty with the Chippewa of the Mississippi & Lake Superior (Treaty of Fond du Lac, Aug. 2, 1847, 9 Stat. 904)
- Treaty with the Chippewa (Treaty of Washington, Feb. 22, 1855, 10 Stat. 1165)
- Treaty with the Chippewa of the Mississippi & the Pillager & Lake Winnibigoshish Bands (Treaty of Old Crossing, Mar. 11, 1863, 12 Stat. 1249)
- Treaty with the Chippewa of the Mississippi & the Pillager & Lake Winnibigoshish Bands (Treaty of Old Crossing, May 7, 1864, 13 Stat. 693)
- Treaty with the Chippewa of the Mississippi, Mar. 19, 1867, 16 Stat. 719